|
|
|
| United States Patent | 5305370 |
| Link to this page | http://www.wikipatents.com/5305370.html |
| Inventor(s) | Kearns; Lloyd (10833 Scotsman Way, Rancho Cordova, CA 95620);
Petersen; David E. (1888 Blubell Dr., Livermore, CA 94550) |
| Abstract | A personal emergency response system in which a hand held portable
transmitter (12) activates a base unit (14) interfaced with the telephone
network (16) to dial 9-1-1 and permit direct communications with the
operator (18) at the public safety answering point even though the user
(10) is unable to reach a telephone (36). The transmitter (12) activates
the base unit (14) as well as optional remote units (48) located
throughout the user's residence or place of business. The base unit (14)
and remote units (48) include speaker-phone communication capabilities
which permit two-way communications between the user (10) and the 9-1-1
system operator (18). |
|
|
|
Title Information  |
|
|
|
|
|
Drawing from US Patent 5305370 |
|
|
Personal emergency response communications system |
|
|
|
|
|
| Publication Date |
April 19, 1994 |
|
|
|
|
|
| Filing Date |
September 4, 1991 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Title Information  |
|
|
References  |
|
|
| *references marked with an asterisk below are user-added references |
|
U.S. References |
|
|
| Add a new US reference: |
| | Reference | Relevancy | Comments | Reference | Relevancy | Comments | 4993058 McMinn
Feb,1991 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4918717 Bissonnette 379/40 Apr,1990 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4908602 Reich 340/514 Mar,1990 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4887291 Stillwell 379/39 Dec,1989 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4884060 Shapiro 340/514 Nov,1989 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4884059 Shapiro 340/514 Nov,1989 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4866764 Barker, III 379/355.01 Sep,1989 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4764757 DeMarco 340/574 Aug,1988 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4763349 Siegel 379/38 Aug,1988 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4760593 Shapiro 379/38 Jul,1988 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4724538 Farrell 455/404.1 Feb,1988 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4656319 Bially 379/29.01 Apr,1987 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4577182 Millsap 340/539.17 Mar,1986 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4571455 Labock 379/40 Feb,1986 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4542262 Ruff 379/56.1 Sep,1985 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4524243 Shapiro 379/38 Jun,1985 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4523307 Brown 370/260 Jun,1985 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4510350 Wagner 379/38 Apr,1985 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4467142 Rupp 379/45 Aug,1984 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4371751 Hilligoss, Jr. 379/41 Feb,1983 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4068097 Verriest 379/38 Jan,1978 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 4064368 Dibner 379/38 Dec,1977 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | 3989900 Dibner 379/50 Nov,1976 |      Your vote accepted [0 after 0 votes] | | | | | |
|
|
|
|
U.S. References |
|
|
Foreign References |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Foreign References |
|
|
Other References |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Other References |
|
|
|
|
|
References  |
|
|
|
|
|
| Market Size |
|
Estimate the gross annual revenues of the relevant market
sector:
|
| | |
| |
|
|
| Market Share |
|
Estimate the percentage of the relevant market sector this invention will capture:
|
| | |
| |
|
|
| Reasonable Royalty |
|
What percentage of gross sales should the inventor or assignee be paid?
|
| | |
| |
|
|
|
Public's "Guesstimation" of Royalty Value
|
| Market Size | N/A | [No votes] | | x | Market Share | N/A | [No votes] | | x | Reasonable Royalty | N/A | [No votes] |
| | N/A | |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Market Review  |
|
|
Technical Review  |
|
|
Claims  |
|
|
I claim:
1. A personal emergency response communications system, comprising:
(a) transmitting means for transmitting a signal indicative of an
emergency, said transmitting means adapted for ready transport by the user
thereof, said transmitting means including a manually operable switch for
activation thereof by said user;
(b) receiving means for receiving said transmitted signal;
(c) control means for accessing a telephone line and dialing 9-1-1, said
control means responsive to said received signal;
(d) comparator means for comparing the duration of said transmitted signal
with a predetermined period of time and preventing said control means from
accessing said telephone line unless the duration of said transmitted
signal exceeds said predetermined period of time;
(e) telephone line interface means for connecting said control means to
said telephone line;
(f) communications means for audible communications between said user and a
9-1-1 system operator, said communications means coupled to said control
means, said communications means operatively responsive to said control
means, said communications means coupled to said telephone line interface
means;
(g) said receiving means, said control means, said comparator means, said
telephone line interface means, and said communications means included
within a base unit; and
(h) dial detection means for accessing said telephone line and activating
said communications means in response to said telephone line being taken
off-hook and 9-1-1 being dialed form an extension telephone coupled to
said telephone line, said dial detection means coupled to said telephone
line interface means, said dial detection means included within said base
unit.
2. The system of claim 1, further comprising silencing means for preventing
said user from receiving audible communications from said 9-1-1 system
operator while permitting said 9-1-1 system operator to receive audible
communications from said user, said silencing means included within said
base unit, said silencing means operable by said user.
3. The system of claim 1, further comprising:
(a) audible annunciating means for alerting said user to activation of said
transmitting means;
(b) visual annunciating means for alerting said use to activation of said
transmitting means; and
(c) means for selectively disabling said audible annunciating means.
4. The system of claim 1, further comprising at lest one remote
communications unit, said remote communications unit operatively
responsive to said control means, said remote communications unit
including means for audible two-way communications between said user and
said 9-1-1 system operator.
5. The system of claim 1, wherein said transmitting means comprises a pulse
code modulated radio frequency transmitter.
6. The system of claim 1, wherein said receiving means comprises:
(a) a radio frequency receiver; and
(b) a pulse code modulation decoder.
7. An apparatus for direct telephone communication with a emergency
response center during a life threatening emergency, comprising:
(a) a radio frequency transmitter, said transmitter including an activation
switch;
(b) a radio frequency receiver;
(c) a telephone dialer, said telephone dialer coupled to said receiver,
said telephone dialer responsive to activation of said transmitter;
(d) a telephone line interface, said telephone line interface coupled to
said receiver, said telephone line interface coupled to said telephone
dialer;
(e) a speaker, said speaker coupled to an amplifier, said amplifier coupled
to said telephone line interface;
(f) a microphone, said microphone coupled to said amplifier; and
(g) silencing means for disabling said speaker while said microphone is
active, said silencing means operatively coupled to said speaker;
(h) said radio frequency receiver, said telephone dialer, said telephone
line interface, said speaker, said microphone, and said silencing means
included within a base unit, said silencing means operable by a user from
said base unit; and
(i) dial detection means for accessing a telephone line coupled to said
telephone line interface and activating said communications means in
response to said telephone line being taking off-hook and 9-1-1 being
dialed from an extension telephone coupled to said telephone line, said
dial detection means coupled to said telephone line interface means, said
dial detection means included within said base unit.
8. The apparatus recited in claim 7, wherein said transmitter includes a
visual annunciator, said visual annunciator responsive to said activation
switch, an audible annunciator, said audible annunciator responsive to
said activation switch, and an annunciator switch, said annunciator switch
operatively coupled said audible annunciator to enable and disable said
audible annunciator.
9. The apparatus recited in claim 7, further comprising
comparator means for comparing the duration of a signal from said
transmitter with a predetermined period of time and preventing operation
of said telephone dialer unless the duration of said transmitted signal
exceeds said predetermined period of time, said comparator means included
within said base unit.
10. The apparatus recited in claim 7, further comprising at least one
remote communications unit, said remote communications unit including a
power line carrier interface, said remote communications unit operatively
responsive to said receiver, said remote communications unit including a
speaker, said remote communications unit including a microphone.
11. An apparatus for communicating with the operator of the 9-1-1 emergency
response system for requesting assistance during an emergency in which the
user is unable to physically reach a telephone, comprising:
(a) a self-contained portable radio frequency transmitter, said transmitter
including an activation switch, said transmitter including a pulse code
modulation encoder;
(b) a base unit, said base unit including a radio frequency receiver, said
base unit including a pulse code modulation decoder coupled to said radio
frequency receiver, said base unit including a control module, said
control module coupled to said pulse code modulation decoder;
(c) a telephone line interface network, said telephone line interface
network coupled to said control module;
(d) a telephone dialer, said telephone dialer coupled to said control
module, said telephone dialer coupled to said telephone line interface
network, said telephone dialer programmed to dial 9-1-1 upon activation of
said transmitter;
(e) a least one speaker coupled to an amplifier, said amplifier coupled to
said telephone line interface network;
(f) at least one microphone coupled to said amplifier, whereby activation
of said transmitter causes said base unit to dial 9-1-1 permitting a user
to communicate with said operator of said 9-1-1 emergency response system;
and
(g) dial detection means for activating said speaker and microphone in
response to a telephone line coupled to said telephone line interface
network being taken off-hook and 9-1-1 being dialed by an extension
telephone coupled to said telephone line, said dial detection means
coupled to said telephone line interface network.
12. The apparatus recited in claim 11, further comprising:
(a) a power line carrier communications interface, said power line carrier
communications interface coupled to said amplifier;
(b) at least one remote communications unit, said remote communications
unit including a power line carrier communications interface, said remote
communications unit including a speaker, said remote communications unit
including a microphone, said remote communications unit operatively
response to said base unit.
13. The apparatus recited in claim 11, further comprising trigger sampling
means for comparing the duration of a radio frequency signal emitted from
said transmitter with a predetermined period of time and preventing
operation of said telephone dialer unless the duration of said transmitted
signal exceeds said predetermined period of time, said trigger sampling
means coupled to said decoder, said trigger sampling means coupled to said
control module, said control module responsive to said trigger sampling
means.
14. The apparatus recited in claim 11, further comprising:
(a) a visual annunciator, said visual annunciator responsive to said
activation switch;
(b) an audible annunciator, said audible annunciator responsive to said
activation switch;
(c) a bypass switch, said control unit operatively responsive to said
bypass switch; and
(d) a cancel switch, said cancel switch coupled to said control module,
said cancel switch deactivating said base unit. |
|
|
|
|
Claims  |
|
|
Description  |
|
|
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
1. Field of the Invention
This invention relates generally to personal emergency response systems,
and more particularly to a remotely controlled system for activating the
enhanced 911 emergency response system and communicating with the 911
dispatcher during an emergency.
2. Description of the Background Art
Various forms of personal alarm systems have been developed which permit
the user to send a transmission to a monitoring station during an
emergency. Typically the user activates a transmitter or other device
located at his or her residence or place of business, and the transmitter
in turn activates a remote subscriber station which communicates with the
monitoring station at another location. Upon activation of the subscriber
unit in response to a predetermined event, an alarm message is transmitted
via a communications link to the monitoring station. The monitoring
station responds to alarm messages generated by the remote station.
Emergency assistance in the form of voluntary responders (e.g, friends,
neighbors, etc.) is then sent in response to the alarm received by the
monitoring station. Once the voluntary responder arrives on the scene and
determines that a life threatening emergency exists, the responder dials
9-1-1 for the victim.
Various forms of communications links are used to permit the remote
subscriber station to communicate with the monitoring station. Those
communications links include telephone lines, cable television
transmission lines, radio frequency paths or dedicated land lines. Most
systems utilize telephone lines because they are widely available and
require minimal installation expense.
Remote subscriber units typically come in various forms, such as those
which are automatically activated upon expiration of a predetermined time
period and reset by operation of electrical switches, television sets,
radios, refrigerators, stoves or telephones; those which use hard wired
activators; and those which use portable transmitters using radio
frequency, infrared or ultrasonic transmission media. Most systems utilize
a hand held radio frequency transmitter for activating the remote
subscriber unit.
Examples of such devices and systems can be found in U.S. Pat. No.
4,510,350 issued to Wagner et al. on Apr. 9, 1985 which discloses a wrist
worn transmitter with a push button trigger, and a base receiver unit
attached to the telephone lines. Upon activation of the transmitter, the
base unit dials the first of up to four stored telephone numbers and plays
a digitized message. The recipient of the message can stop or repeat the
message using touch tone signals; U.S. Pat. No. 4,524,243 issued to
Shapiro on Jun. 18, 1985 which discloses a personal alarm system which is
triggered by the failure of the subscriber to activate a reset switch
within a predetermined period of time; U.S. Pat. No. 4,064,368 issued to
Dibner on Dec. 20, 1977 which discloses a digital dialer-transceiver
connected to a telephone line which is triggered by an emergency button or
the running out of a timer. When activated, the transceiver transmits
identification and alarm codes to a compatible digital transceiver at a
monitoring station and at the same time emits an alarm signal at the
residence. The monitoring station operator then contacts care-givers who
go to the residence and reset the unit; U.S. Pat. No. 3,989,900 issued to
Dibner on Nov. 2, 1976 which discloses an alarm system for automatically
sending a telephone message or other remote signal in case help is needed
by a person residing alone. In one version, the telephone is automatically
dialed at predetermined intervals and an audible warning is sounded so
that the person can abort the message. In another version, a high speed
digital dialer and transmitter are used; U.S. Pat. No. 4,884,059 issued to
Shapiro on Nov. 28, 1989 which discloses test equipment for use with
emergency response systems wherein subscriber units are activated and
signals or messages are sent to a monitoring station via radio or
telephone communications links; U.S. Pat. No. 4,908,602 issued to Reich et
al. on Mar. 13, 1990 which discloses an apparatus and method for testing a
portable held button for an emergency response system; U.S. Pat. No.
4,884,060 issued to Shapiro on Nov. 28, 1989 which discloses a multi-state
selection switch for a personal emergency response system; German No.
2703923 which discloses a personalized alarm system which couples an
individual with a central monitoring station with a transmitter-receiver.
The signals from the transmitter-receiver are passed to the monitoring
station containing a facility for timing signals and generating signals
requiring a response. The system is readily adapted to allow the
generation of a specific range of call signals, that in extreme cases
provide automatic connection to the police services; French No. 2449934
which discloses an apparatus for sending prerecorded messages to an
emergency service monitoring station; German No. 2743476 which discloses a
personal protection system having a portable transceiver with coded
functions for transmitting emergency signals to a monitoring station;
French No. 2575125 which discloses a portable transmitter with a
multi-state warning signal. When the transmitter button is pushed for a
short period, a warning of risk is sent. When the button is held down for
longer than two seconds, an emergency is declared; U.S. Pat. No. 4,887,291
issued to Stillwell on Dec. 12, 1989 which discloses a monitoring system
for annunciating emergencies; U.S. Pat. No. 4,724,538 issued to Farrell on
Feb. 9, 1988 which discloses an emergency roadside telephone
communications system; U.S. Pat. No. 4,577,182 issued to Millsap et al. on
Mar. 18, 1986 which discloses a cellular based radio alarm system; and
U.S. Pat. No. 4,656,319 issued to Bially on Apr. 7, 1987 which discloses
an alarm system tester for verifying operation of subscriber stations.
Although the foregoing patents describe devices and systems which can dial
telephones or send alarm signals, none of them permit the user to
communicate directly with the monitoring station operator or, in
particular, a 9-1-1 dispatcher during an emergency, via standard telephone
lines. Therefore, it is not possible for the monitoring station operator
to know the exact nature of a personal emergency. Systems such as these
are the source of frequent false alarms and often lengthy delays due to
the number or "middle men" involved before the victim receives the proper
emergency assistance (e.g., fire, police, paramedics, etc.) Delays of over
thirty minutes are not uncommon.
The foregoing patents reflect the state of the art of which the applicant
is aware and are tendered with the view toward discharging applicant's
acknowledged duty of candor in disclosing information which may be
pertinent in the examination of this application. It is respectfully
stipulated, however, that none of these patents teach or render obvious,
singly or when considered in combination, applicant's invention.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
In general terms, the apparatus of the present invention includes a
self-contained portable transmitter, a base unit which includes a
receiver, decoder, telephone line interface and control circuit, and one
or more optional remote speaker/microphone units. During a life
threatening emergency or a crime in progress, a person who is injured,
physically threatened, or otherwise unable to reach a telephone, can
activate the portable transmitter to summon help. The transmitter, which
is carried or worn by the user, has an activation button and two
annunciators. One annunciator is visual, while the other is audible. When
the transmitter is activated, the audible annunciator beeps and the visual
annunciator comes on. This feature helps to protect against false alarms
resulting from the user inadvertently striking the activation button.
A base unit, which is stationary but can be moved from location to location
if necessary, houses a radio receiver responsive to the transmitter.
Through the use of pulse code modulation and decoding techniques, both the
transmitter and the receiver can be set to any one of up to 262,143 unique
codes to eliminate interference from other users. A control module in the
base unit links the receiver to a dialer unit programmed to dial 9-1-1, a
telephone line interface network, and a speaker and microphone driven by
amplifiers in a speaker-phone configuration.
Activation of the transmitter causes the control module to take the
telephone line "off-hook" and dial 9-1-1. When the 9-1-1 system operator
answers, the person requiring assistance can communicate with the system
operator even though they are located away from the base unit and could
not otherwise reach a telephone. In order to provide complete
communicative coverage in the event that the user experiences an emergency
in a room where the base unit is not physically located, optional remote
speaker/microphone units can be used. These units, which are typically
plugged into an A/C power outlet, use a power line carrier communications
interface as a link to the base unit and provide equivalent speaker-phone
capabilities.
The base unit also continuously monitors the telephone line to determine if
an extension telephone is taken "off-hook" and the first three digits of
the telephone number 9-1-1 are dialed. In that event, the base unit and
remote speaker/microphone units are activated so as to alert persons in
their proximity that 9-1-1 has been dialed.
Additionally, a silent mode can be invoked to disable the speakers and
audible annunciators used in the system. This mode is particularly suited
for retail establishments which are prone to hold-ups and robberies
because the intruder will not be alerted by the 9-1-1 system operator,
although the 9-1-1 system operator would be able to listen to what was
taking place in order to better ascertain the nature of the emergency.
An object of the invention is to provide better and more effective
communications between the 9-1-1 operator and a person requiring emergency
assistance.
Another object of the invention is to provide better and more effective
communications between the 9-1-1 operator and persons at the scene of an
emergency who are attempting to render assistance.
Another object of the invention is to provide two-way communications
capabilities between the 9-1-1 operator and a person who requires
emergency assistance but who is unable to reach a telephone.
Another object of the invention is to provide two-way communications
capabilities between the 9-1-1 operator and a person who requires
emergency assistance where no telephone is present.
Another object of the invention is to provide a system whereby police,
during a hold-up or other type of emergency in a commercial establishment,
can determine the nature of the emergency rather than respond only to an
alarm.
Another object of the invention is to reduce the frequency of false alarms
received by the 9-1-1 operator.
Another object of the invention is to permit persons in a business
establishment to directly summon police during an armed robbery or other
emergency without alerting the intruder.
Another object of the invention is to permit the police or 9-1-1 operator
to monitor audible activity during an armed robbery or hostage situation
without alerting the intruder.
Another object of the invention is to reduce the number of deaths resulting
from emergencies to which there is no response because the victim is
unable to summon assistance.
Another object of the invention is to facilitate verification by the 9-1-1
operator that an emergency exists and assistance is required.
Another object of the invention is to reduce unnecessary emergency
responses when a child has inadvertently dialed 9-1-1 and left the
telephone off hook.
Another object of the invention is to provide for quicker response time to
assist victims of crimes in the home or place of business.
Another object of the invention is to activate video surveillance systems
in retail establishments when 9-1-1 is dialed.
Another object of the invention is to provide for quicker response time to
assist victims of heart attack, stroke or other life threatening
emergencies where response time is crucial.
Another object of the invention is to provide a more affordable emergency
response system by eliminating the monthly monitoring fee required by all
other systems.
Another object of the invention is to provide assistance to a victim who is
unable to speak and unable to reach a telephone.
Further objects and advantages of the invention will be brought out in the
following portions of the specification, wherein the detailed description
is for the purpose of fully disclosing preferred embodiments of the
invention without placing limitations thereon.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
The invention will be more fully understood by reference to the following
drawings which are for illustrative purposes only:
FIG. 1 is a functional block diagram of the present invention.
FIG. 2 is a system block diagram of the present invention.
FIG. 3 is a functional block diagram of the remote transmitter shown in
FIG. 2.
FIG. 4 is a functional block diagram of the base unit shown in FIG. 2.
FIG. 5 is a functional block diagram of the remote speaker/microphone unit
shown in FIG. 2.
DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
Referring more specifically to the drawings, for illustrative purposes the
present invention is embodied in the system and apparatus generally shown
in FIG. 1 through FIG. 5. It will be appreciated that the system and
apparatus may vary as to configuration and as to details of the parts
without departing from the basic concepts as disclosed herein.
Referring to FIG. 1, in general terms the system of the present invention
permits a user 10 to carry with them a remote transmitter 12 which can be
activated in an emergency. Ideally suited for elderly persons living
alone, activation of remote transmitter 12 will cause base unit 14, which
is interfaced with the telephone lines 16, to automatically dial the
enhanced 9-1-1 system operator 18 and activate a two-way speaker phone
integrated within base unit 14. The 9-1-1 system operator can then
communicate directly with user 10, ascertain the nature of the emergency
even though user 10 is unable to reach a telephone, and dispatch the
appropriate emergency service 20 in response. Even if the victim is unable
to speak, the 9-1-1 system operator will know the address of the victim by
the automatic location identifier (ALI) 17, which is part of the enhanced
9-1-1 system.
Referring also FIG. 2, remote transmitter 12 includes emergency activation
button 22 and a case 24 which houses its associated components. Remote
transmitter 12 also includes visual indicator 26 and audible indicator 28,
both of which are responsive to activation of remote transmitter 12. Base
unit 14 includes antenna 30 for receiving signals from remote transmitter
12 and cable 32 with modular plug 34 for interfacing base unit 14 with the
telephone lines 16. Base unit 14 also includes a modular jack 92 (FIG. 4)
for connecting a telephone set 36 if desired, and an A/C power connector
38. Speaker 40 is provided to permit the user 10 to listen to
communications from the 9-1-1 system operator 18 and microphone 42 is
provided to permit the user 10 to talk to the 9-1-1 system operator 18. An
emergency bypass switch 44 is provided to permit the user 10 to activate
the system without using remote transmitter 12, and a cancel switch 46 is
provided to permit the user 10 to terminate the call. Remote
speaker/microphone units 48 are installed at various locations throughout
the residence or place of business of user 10 so that user 10 can
communicate with the 9-1-1 system operator 18 even though user 10 is in
another room or otherwise not in proximity to base unit 14. Remote
speaker/microphone units 48 include A/C power connector 50.
Referring now to FIG. 3, remote transmitter 12 is a small, portable,
battery powered device for transmitting a pulse code modulated (PCM) radio
frequency carrier. Remote transmitter 12 incorporates a user selected
digital code of 9 to 18 eighteen bits of data to provide 511 to 262,143
different codes. The desired digital code is selected with code set
switches 52. The power output of remote transmitter 12 is limited so as to
permit use of numerous unlicensed frequencies.
Emergency activation button 22 is recessed into transmitter case 24.
Depressing emergency activation button 22 connects power supply 54 which
is a battery or the like to a digital PCM encoder 56 and oscillator 58.
PCM encoder 56, which is typically an MC145028 or the like, modulates
oscillator 58 on and off with the selected digital code. This resultant
pulsed radio frequency carrier is then transmitted by means of antenna
tank circuit 60 contained within case 24. Visual indicator 26 and audible
indicator 28 show that remote transmitter 12 has been activated and, by
providing such positive indication that the system has been a | | |