WikiPatents - Community Patent Review
Create Free Account  |  License or Sell Your Patent  |  WikiPatents Marketplace  |  WikiPatents Blog
Username:  Password:  
    
Advanced Search
Method for evaluation of health care quality    
United States Patent5544044   
Link to this pagehttp://www.wikipatents.com/5544044.html
Inventor(s)Leatherman; Sheila (Minneapolis, MN)
AbstractA software-based medical information system performs a method of analyzing health care claims records for an enrolled population (e.g., HMO, Medicaid) to assess and report on quality of care based on conformance to nationally recognized medical practice guidelines or quality indicators. The system analyzes health care received by enrollees having a specified health care condition by: providing to the system health care claims records for a selected enrollee population; defining at least one health care condition in terms of health care events reportable in health care claims records; identifying in the health care claims records those enrollees meeting the definition for that health care condition; defining health care quality criteria for that health care condition in terms of health care events reportable in health care claims records; comparing the health care quality criteria for the at least one health care condition to the health care claims records for at least a portion of those enrollees meeting the definition for that health care condition; and developing and outputting from the system a health care quality report based on the comparison and formulating action recommendations to improve care. The system provides an efficient means to supplement claims data with data from patient medical records.



 Title Information Submit all comments and votes
 
Patent Text Patent PDF Print Page Summary File History
Plain text PDF images Print Summary File History
Drawing from US Patent 5544044
Method for evaluation of health care quality - US Patent 5544044 Drawing
Method for evaluation of health care quality
Inventor     Leatherman; Sheila (Minneapolis, MN)
Owner/Assignee     United Healthcare Corporation (Minneapolis, MN)
Patent assignment
All assignments
Publication Date     August 6, 1996
Application Number     07/739,629
PAIR File History     Application Data   Transaction History
Image File Wrapper   Patent Term   Fees
Litigation
Filing Date     August 2, 1991
US Classification     705/3 600/508 705/2
Int'l Classification     G06F 159/00
Examiner     Hayes; Gail O.
Assistant Examiner     Poinvil; Frantzy
Attorney/Law Firm     Dorsey & Whitney LLP
Address
Parent Case    
Priority Data    
USPTO Field of Search     364/413.01 364/2 364/3 364/4 364/5 364/6 364/7 364/8 364/9 364/10 364/11 364/12 364/13 364/14 364/15 364/16 364/17 364/18 364/19 364/20 364/21 364/22 364/23 364/24 364/25 364/26 364/27 364/28 364/29 364/30 364/31 364/32 364/33 364/34 364/35 364/36 364/37 364/38 364/39 364/40 364/41 364/42 364/43 364/44 364/45 364/46 364/47 364/48 364/49 364/50 364/51 364/52 364/53 364/54 364/55 364/56 364/57 364/58 364/59 364/60 364/61 364/62 364/63 364/64 364/65 364/66 364/67 364/68 364/69 364/70 364/71 364/72 364/73 364/74 364/75 364/76 364/77 364/78 364/79 364/80 364/81 364/82 364/83 364/84 364/85 364/86 364/87 364/88 364/89 364/90 364/91 364/92 364/93 364/94 364/95 364/96 364/97 364/98 364/99 364/100 364/101 364/102 364/103 364/104 364/105 364/106 364/107 364/108 364/109 364/110 364/111 364/112 364/113 364/114 364/115 364/116 364/117 364/118 364/119 364/120 364/121 364/122 364/123 364/124 364/125 364/126 364/127 364/128 364/129 364/130 364/131 364/132 364/133 364/134 364/135 364/136 364/137 364/138 364/139 364/140 364/141 364/142 364/143 364/144 364/145 364/146 364/147 364/148 364/149 364/150 364/151 364/152 364/153 364/154 364/155 364/156 364/157 364/158 364/159 364/160 364/161 364/162 364/163 364/164 364/165 364/166 364/167 364/168 364/169 364/170 364/171 364/172 364/173 364/174 364/175 364/176 364/177 364/178 364/179 364/180 364/181 364/182 364/183 364/184 364/185 364/186 364/187 364/188 364/189 364/190 364/191 364/192 364/193 364/194 364/195 364/196 364/197 364/198 364/199 364/200 364/201 364/202 364/203 364/204 364/205 364/206 364/207 364/208 364/209 364/210 364/211 364/212 364/213 364/214 364/215 364/216 364/217 364/218 364/219 364/220 364/221 364/222 364/223 364/224 364/225 364/226 364/227 364/228 364/229 364/230 364/231 364/232 364/233 364/234 364/235 364/236 364/237 364/238 364/239 364/240 364/241 364/242 364/243 364/244 364/245 364/246 364/247 364/248 364/249 364/250 364/251 364/252 364/253 364/254 364/255 364/256 364/257 364/258 364/259 364/260 364/261 364/262 364/263 364/264 364/265 364/266 364/267 364/268 364/269 364/270 364/271 364/272 364/273 364/274 364/275 364/276 364/277 364/278 364/279 364/280 364/281 364/282 364/283 364/284 364/285 364/286 364/287 364/288 364/289 364/290 364/291 364/292 364/293 364/294 364/295 364/296 364/297 364/298 364/299 364/300 364/301 364/302 364/303 364/304 364/305 364/306 364/307 364/308 364/309 364/310 364/311 364/312 364/313 364/314 364/315 364/316 364/317 364/318 364/319 364/320 364/321 364/322 364/323 364/324 364/325 364/326 364/327 364/328 364/329 364/330 364/331 364/332 364/333 364/334 364/335 364/336 364/337 364/338 364/339 364/340 364/341 364/342 364/343 364/344 364/345 364/346 364/347 364/348 364/349 364/350 364/351 364/352 364/353 364/354 364/355 364/356 364/357 364/358 364/359 364/360 364/361 364/362 364/363 364/364 364/365 364/366 364/367 364/368 364/369 364/370 364/371 364/372 364/373 364/374 364/375 364/376 364/377 364/378 364/379 364/380 364/381 364/382 364/383 364/384 364/385 364/386 364/387 364/388 364/389 364/390 364/391 364/392 364/393 364/394 364/395 364/396 364/397 364/398 364/399 364/400 364/401 364/402 364/403 364/404 364/405 364/406 364/407 364/408 364/409 364/410 364/411 364/412 364/413.04 364/413.02 364/414.415 364/413.01 364/413.02 128/696
Patent Tags     evaluation health care quality
   
Enter a comma (,) or semicolon (;) between multiple tag words/phrases.
Describe this patent:
 Amusing   
 Clever   
 Complex   
 Efficient   
 Historic   
 Important   
 Innovative   
 Interesting   
 Practical   
 Simple   
[no votes]
Patent WIKI

Share information and news about this patent, including information and news about the technology, inventors, company, ligation and licensing.

 References Submit all comments and votes
 
*references marked with an asterisk below are user-added references
 U.S. References
 
Add a new US reference:  
ReferenceRelevancyCommentsReferenceRelevancyComments
5018067
Mohlenbrock
600/300
May,1991

[0 after 0 votes]
4878175
Norden-Paul
705/2
Oct,1989

[0 after 0 votes]
4737912
Ichikawa
600/301
Apr,1988

[0 after 0 votes]
4667292
Mohlenbrock
705/2
May,1987

[0 after 0 votes]
3872448
Mitchell, Jr.
705/3
Mar,1975

[0 after 0 votes]
 Foreign References
 Other References
 Market Review Submit all comments and votes
   
Market Size
Estimate the gross annual revenues of the relevant market sector:
> $10B
$5B - $10B
$2B - $5B
$500M - $2B
$100M - $500M
$10M - $100M
$1M - $10M
$500K - $1M
$100K - $500K
< $100K
[No votes]
$0
 
$0   $2.5B   $5B   $7.5B   $10B
Market Share
Estimate the percentage of the relevant market sector this invention will capture:
75% - 100%
50% - 74.99%
25% - 49.99%
10 - 24.99%
5 - 9.99%
2 - 4.99%
1 - 1.99%
< 1%
[No votes]
0.0%
 
0%   25%   50%   75%   100%
Reasonable Royalty
What percentage of gross sales should the inventor or assignee be paid?
75% - 100%
50% - 74.99%
25% - 49.99%
10 - 24.99%
5 - 9.99%
2 - 4.99%
1 - 1.99%
< 1%
[No votes]
0.0%
 
0%   25%   50%   75%   100%
Public's "Guesstimation" of Royalty Value
Market SizeN/A[No votes]
xMarket ShareN/A[No votes]
xReasonable RoyaltyN/A[No votes]

N/A

License Availablity
If you are NOT the owner or assignee, answer here:
Yes, license is available for purchase

No, license is not currently available



[No votes]
License Availablity
If you ARE the owner or assignee, answer here:
Yes, license is available for purchase

No, license is not currently available



[No votes]
Competitive Advantage
Does this invention have a significant competitive advantage over similar technologies?
Yes

No



[No votes]
Most helpful competitive advantage comment
[No comments]

Commercial Alternatives
Are there viable commercial alternatives for this invention?
Yes

No



[No votes]
Most helpful commercial alternative comment
[No comments]

 Technical Review Submit all comments and votes
 Claims Submit all comments and votes
 


What is claimed is:

1. In a medical information system comprising a processing unit, at least one memory unit and means for entering information into said medical information system and for providing commands to said medical information system, a method of analyzing health care claims records for an enrolled population to assess quality of care received by enrollees having a specified health care condition and formulate action recommendations to improve care comprising:

(a) providing to said processing unit of said medical information system health care claims records for a selected enrollee population;

(b) defining in the medical information system at least one health care condition in terms of a specified logical relationship among a plurality of health care events relevant to diagnosis and reported in the health care claims records;

(c) identifying in the health care claims records those enrollees meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition;

(d) defining in the medical information system health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition in terms of a plurality of health care events reported or reportable in the health care claims records, including at least one intervention based on practice guidelines and related to care for the at least one health care condition;

(e) comparing the health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition to the health care claims records for at least a portion of those enrollees meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition; and

(f) developing and outputting from said medical information system a health care quality report based on the comparison of step (e) and including action recommendations for improving health care quality.

2. The method of claim 1 wherein the step of providing health care claims records comprises providing records from a group consisting of: claims records for medical professional services, claims records for hospital services and claims records for pharmaceutical prescriptions.

3. The method of claim 1 wherein multiple health care conditions and corresponding health care quality criteria for said multiple health care conditions are defined.

4. The method of claim I further comprising the steps of:

(g) providing to said processing unit of said medical information system medical records for a selected enrollee population that is a subset of the enrollee population identified as meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition;

(h) defining health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition also in terms of health care events reported or reportable in the medical records;

(i) comparing the health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition to the medical records for at least some of those enrollees meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition; and

(j) developing and outputting from said medical information system a report based on the comparison of step (i) as well as step (e) and including action recommendations for improving health care quality as defined by said health care quality criteria.

5. The method of claim 1 wherein the step of defining at least one health care condition in terms of health care events relevant to diagnosis and reported in the health care claims records comprises defining a specific health care condition in the nature of a disease or organic dysfunction.

6. The method of claim 5 wherein the at least one health care condition is selected from a group consisting of: pediatric asthma, diabetes mellitus, hypertension, and breast cancer.

7. The method of claim 1 wherein the step of defining at least one health care condition in terms of health care events relevant to diagnosis and reported in the health care claims records further comprises defining a specific health care condition not in the nature of a disease or organic dysfunction.

8. The method of claim 7 wherein the at least one health care condition is selected from a group consisting of: prenatal care, caesarian section, breast cancer screening, cervical cancer screening and pediatric immunizations for a specified age group.

9. The method of claim 1 wherein step (f) comprises developing and outputting from said medical information system a health care quality report that reports statistics on at least one adverse event as an indicator of a health care quality problem.

10. The method of claim 1 wherein step (f) comprises developing and outputting from said medical information system a health care quality report that reports a frequency of occurrence of at least one health care quality criterion.

11. In a medical information system comprising a processing unit, at least one memory unit and means for entering information into said medical information system and for providing commands to said medical information system, a method of analyzing health care claims records for an enrolled population to assess quality of care received by enrollees having a specified health care condition and formulate action recommendations to improve care comprising:

(a) providing to said processing unit of said medical information system health care claims records for a selected enrollee population, said claims records comprising claims records for medical professional services, claims records for hospital services and claims records for pharmaceutical prescriptions;

(b) defining in the medical information system at least one health care condition in terms of a specified logical relationship among a plurality of health care events relevant to diagnosis and reported in the health care claims records;

(c) identifying in the health care claims records those enrollees meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition;

(d) defining in the medical information system health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition in terms of a plurality of health care events reported or reportable in the health care claims records, including at least one intervention based on practice guidelines and related to care for the at least one health care condition;

(e) comparing the health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition to the health care claims records for at least a portion of those enrollees meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition; and

(f) developing and outputting from said medical information system a health care quality report based on the comparison of step (e) and including action recommendations for improving health care quality as defined by said health care quality criteria.

12. The method of claim 11 wherein multiple health care conditions and corresponding health care quality criteria for said multiple health care conditions are defined.

13. The method of claim 11 further comprising the steps of:

(g) providing to said processing unit of said medical information system medical records for a selected enrollee population that is a subset of the enrollee population identified as meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition;

(h) defining health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition also in terms of health care events reported in the medical records;

(i) comparing the health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition to the medical records for at least some of those enrollees meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition; and

(j) developing and outputting from said medical information system a report based on the comparison of step (i) as well as step (e) and including action recommendations for improving health care quality as defined by said health care quality criteria.

14. A medical information system for analyzing health care claims records for a health care benefit plan to assess quality of care received by plan members having a specified health care condition and formulate action recommendations to improve care comprising:

(a) a central processing unit;

(b) at least one memory unit connected to said central processing unit;

(c) means for providing to said processing unit health care claims records for a selected enrollee population;

(d) means for defining at least one health care condition in terms of a specified logical relationship among a plurality of health care events relevant to diagnosis and reported in the health care claims records;

(e) means for identifying in the health care claims records those enrollees meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition;

(f) means for defining health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition in terms of a plurality of health care events reported or reportable in health care claims records, including at least one intervention based on practice guidelines related to care for the at least one health care condition;

(g) means for comparing the health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition to the health care claims records for at least a portion of those enrollees meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition; and

(h) means for developing and outputting from said medical information system a health care quality report based on the comparison performed by means (g) and including action recommendations for improving health care quality as defined by said health care quality criteria.

15. The system of claim 14 wherein the means for providing health care claims records comprises means for providing records from a group consisting of: claims records for medical professional services, claims records for hospital services and claims records for pharmaceutical prescriptions.

16. The system of claim 14 further comprising:

(i) means for providing to said processing unit of said medical information system medical records for a selected enrollee population that is a subset of the enrollee population identified as meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition;

(j) means for defining health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition also in terms of health care events reported or reportable in the medical records;

(k) means for comparing the health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition to the medical records for at least some of those enrollees meeting the definition for said at least one health care condition; and

(l) means for developing and outputting from said medical information system a report based on the comparison performed by means (k) as well as means (g) and including action recommendations for improving health care quality as defined by said health care quality criteria.

17. A medical information system for analyzing records for a health care benefit plan, wherein said medical information system assesses quality of care received by plan members having a specified health care condition and formulates action recommendations to improve care, said medical information system comprising:

(a) a processor;

(b) a database, accessible by said processor, wherein said database includes information from health care claim records for a selected enrollee population that is a subset of the enrollee population identified as meeting said definition for said at least one health care condition;

(c) a data storage medium accessible by the processor, wherein the data storage medium has a program stored on it, and wherein the program is configured to cause the processor to:

define at least one health care condition in terms of a specified logical relationship among a plurality of health care events relevant to diagnosis and reported or reportable in said health care claims records,

define health care quality criteria in terms of a plurality of health care events reported or reportable in said health care claims records, including at least one intervention based on practice guidelines and related to care for said at least one health care condition,

identify enrollees meeting said definition for said at least one health care condition,

compare health care quality criteria for said at least one health care condition to said information from said health care claims records for at least a portion of those enrollees meeting said definition for said at least one health care condition, and

formulate action recommendations for improving health care quality as defined by said health care quality criteria; and

(d) an output device, connected to the processor, for outputting from said medical information system a health care quality report.

18. A medical information system as claimed in claim 17, wherein said output device is a printer.

19. A medical information system as claimed in claim 17, wherein said output device is a computer display.

20.