WikiPatents - Community Patent Review
Create Free Account  |  License or Sell Your Patent  |  WikiPatents Marketplace  |  WikiPatents Blog
Username:  Password:  
    
Advanced Search
Method for detecting changes in preload on a tie rod installed as part of a core shroud repair in a boiling water reactor    

Custom CD of patents similar to US5589640 : Method for detecting changes in preload on a tie rod installed as part of a core shroud repair in a boiling water reactor - $19.95
United States Patent5589640   
Link to this pagehttp://www.wikipatents.com/5589640.html
Inventor(s)Butler; Patrick J. (6909 Duke Dr., Alexandria, VA 22307)
AbstractIn a boiling water reactor having a core shroud disposed within a reactor vessel and a plurality of tie rods installed between vertically spaced sites on the core shroud as part of a core shroud repair, a method of measuring tie rod preload after installation includes the steps of lowering a tool into the reactor vessel from a remote location positioned externally of the reactor vessel, attaching the tool to an upper portion of a tie rod, using the tool to apply a tensile load along a longitudinal axis of the tie rod, measuring the tensile load applied to the tie rod, measuring axial displacement of the tie rod in response to the applied tensile load, plotting the applied load versus the axial displacement measured, and identifying a change in slope on the load-displacement plot occurring at a load corresponding to the tie rod preload.
   














 Title Information Submit all comments and votes
 
Patent Text Patent PDF Print Page Summary File History
Plain text PDF images Print Summary File History
Drawing from US Patent 5589640
Method for detecting changes in preload on a tie rod installed as part

     of a core shroud repair in a boiling water reactor - US Patent 5589640 Drawing
Method for detecting changes in preload on a tie rod installed as part of a core shroud repair in a boiling water reactor
Inventor     Butler; Patrick J. (6909 Duke Dr., Alexandria, VA 22307)
Owner/Assignee    
Patent assignment
All assignments
Company News
Publication Date     December 31, 1996
Application Number     08/627,154
PAIR File History     Application Data   Transaction History
Image File Wrapper   Patent Term   Fees
Litigation
Filing Date     April 3, 1996
US Classification     73/761 73/785 376/258 376/260
Int'l Classification     F16B 031/02
Examiner     Chilcot; Richard
Assistant Examiner     Amrozowicz; Paul D.
Attorney/Law Firm    
Address
Parent Case    
Priority Data    
USPTO Field of Search     73/761 73/831 73/846 73/853 73/856 376/258 376/260 376/290 376/292 376/302 376/303 376/362 376/363 376/370 376/389 376/390
Patent Tags     detecting changes preload tie rod installed part core shroud repair boiling water reactor
   
Enter a comma (,) or semicolon (;) between multiple tag words/phrases.
Describe this patent:
 Amusing   
 Clever   
 Complex   
 Efficient   
 Historic   
 Important   
 Innovative   
 Interesting   
 Practical   
 Simple   
[no votes]
Patent WIKI

Share information and news about this patent, including information and news about the technology, inventors, company, ligation and licensing.

 References Submit all comments and votes
 
*references marked with an asterisk below are user-added references
 U.S. References
 
Add a new US reference:  
ReferenceRelevancyCommentsReferenceRelevancyComments
3837694



[0 after 0 votes]
3844533



[0 after 0 votes]
3877326



[0 after 0 votes]
3008362



[0 after 0 votes]
3015975



[0 after 0 votes]
3115332



[0 after 0 votes]
3162071



[0 after 0 votes]
3382709



[0 after 0 votes]
3561260



[0 after 0 votes]
3722332



[0 after 0 votes]
5502754
Erbes
376/302
Mar,1996

[0 after 0 votes]
5452629
Heiermann

Sep,1995

[0 after 0 votes]
5402570
Weems
29/890.031
Apr,1995

[0 after 0 votes]
5392322
Whitling
376/260
Feb,1995

[0 after 0 votes]
5343785
Holt
81/57.38
Sep,1994

[0 after 0 votes]
4659065
Simms
254/29A
Apr,1987

[0 after 0 votes]
4535656
Orban
81/57.38
Aug,1985

[0 after 0 votes]
4494412
Hardy
73/761
Jan,1985

[0 after 0 votes]
4454790
Rieben
81/57.38
Jun,1984

[0 after 0 votes]
4333351
Bickford
73/761
Jun,1982

[0 after 0 votes]
4295393
Adcock
81/57.4
Oct,1981

[0 after 0 votes]
4273011
Exner
81/57.38
Jun,1981

[0 after 0 votes]
4185504
Exner
73/761
Jan,1980

[0 after 0 votes]
4185505
Exner
73/761
Jan,1980

[0 after 0 votes]
4185506
Exner
73/761
Jan,1980

[0 after 0 votes]
4175453
Exner
81/57.38
Nov,1979

[0 after 0 votes]
4062227
Heyman
73/630
Dec,1977

[0 after 0 votes]
4047456
Scholz
81/57.38
Sep,1977

[0 after 0 votes]
4027559
Wallrafen
81/57.38
Jun,1977

[0 after 0 votes]
3995828
Orban
254/29A
Dec,1976

[0 after 0 votes]
3969810
Pagano
29/407.02
Jul,1976

[0 after 0 votes]
3943819
Charron
411/14
Mar,1976

[0 after 0 votes]
3759090
McFaul
73/597
Sep,1973

[0 after 0 votes]
3969960

81/429
Dec,1969

[0 after 0 votes]
 Foreign References
 Other References
 Market Review Submit all comments and votes
   
Market Size
Estimate the gross annual revenues of the relevant market sector:
> $10B
$5B - $10B
$2B - $5B
$500M - $2B
$100M - $500M
$10M - $100M
$1M - $10M
$500K - $1M
$100K - $500K
< $100K
[No votes]
$0
 
$0   $2.5B   $5B   $7.5B   $10B

[0 market size comments]
Market Share
Estimate the percentage of the relevant market sector this invention will capture:
75% - 100%
50% - 74.99%
25% - 49.99%
10 - 24.99%
5 - 9.99%
2 - 4.99%
1 - 1.99%
< 1%
[No votes]
0.0%
 
0%   25%   50%   75%   100%

[0 market share comments]
Reasonable Royalty
What percentage of gross sales should the inventor or assignee be paid?
75% - 100%
50% - 74.99%
25% - 49.99%
10 - 24.99%
5 - 9.99%
2 - 4.99%
1 - 1.99%
< 1%
[No votes]
0.0%
 
0%   25%   50%   75%   100%

[0 reasonable royalty comments]
Public's "Guesstimation" of Royalty Value
Market SizeN/A[No votes]
xMarket ShareN/A[No votes]
xReasonable RoyaltyN/A[No votes]

N/A

[0 Guesstimation of Royalty Value Comments]
License Availablity
If you are NOT the owner or assignee, answer here:
Yes, license is available for purchase

No, license is not currently available



[No votes]
[0 license availability comments]
License Availablity
If you ARE the owner or assignee, answer here:
Yes, license is available for purchase

No, license is not currently available



[No votes]
[0 owner/assignee comments]
Competitive Advantage
Does this invention have a significant competitive advantage over similar technologies?
Yes

No



[No votes]
Most helpful competitive advantage comment
[No comments]

[0 competitive advantage comments]
Commercial Alternatives
Are there viable commercial alternatives for this invention?
Yes

No



[No votes]
Most helpful commercial alternative comment
[No comments]

[0 commercial alternatives comments]
 Technical Review Submit all comments and votes
 Claims Submit all comments and votes
 


What is claimed is:

1. In a boiling water reactor having a core shroud disposed within a reactor vessel and a plurality of tie rods installed with an initial preload between vertically spaced sites on the core shroud at a respective plurality of angularly spaced locations about the shroud periphery as part of a core shroud repair, a method of measuring preload on an installed tie rod to determine whether the preload on the tie rod has changed since installation, said method comprising the steps of

(a) lowering a tool into the reactor vessel from a remote location positioned externally of the reactor vessel;

(b) attaching the tool to an upper portion of the tie rod;

(c) using the tool to apply a tensile load along a longitudinal axis of the tie rod;

(d) measuring the tensile load as it is applied to the tie rod;

(e) measuring axial displacement of the tie rod as the tensile load is applied;

(f) plotting the load measured in step (d) versus the axial displacement measured in step (e); and

(g) identifying a change in slope on the load-displacement plot occurring at a load corresponding to the tie rod preload.

2. A method of measuring preload on a tie rod in a boiling water reactor as recited in claim 1 wherein step (a) includes (a.1) attaching a pole to the tool and (a.2) using the pole to lower the tool into a reactor vessel from the remote location.

3. A method of measuring preload on a tie rod in a boiling water reactor as recited in claim 1 wherein step (b) includes (b.1) threading the tool onto the upper portion of the tie rod.

4. A method of measuring preload on a tie rod in a boiling water reactor as recited in claim 3 wherein step (b.1) includes (b.1.1) threading a movable portion of the tool onto the upper portion of the tie rod and (b.1.2) reacting a stationary portion of the tool against an upper portion of the shroud.

5. A method of measuring preload on a tie rod in a boiling water reactor as recited in claim 4 wherein step (c) includes (c.1) forcing the movable portion of the tool in an upward, vertical direction along a longitudinal axis of the tie rod.

6. A method of measuring preload on a tie rod in a boiling water reactor as recited in claim 5 wherein the stationary portion of the tool includes a hydraulic cylinder and step (c.1) includes (c.1.1) operating a pump at the remote location to pressurize the cylinder.

7. A method of measuring preload on a tie rod in a boiling water reactor as recited in claim 6 wherein step (d) includes (d.1) viewing a pressure gauge attached to the pump.

8. A method of measuring preload on a tie rod in a boiling water reactor as recited in claim 5 wherein step (e) includes (e.1) measuring the axial displacement of the movable portion.

9. A method of measuring preload on a tie rod in a boiling water reactor as recited in claim 8 wherein step (e.1) includes (e.1.1) mounting a dial indicator on the stationary portion of the tool with a plunger contacting the movable portion of the tool.

10. A method of measuring preload on a tie rod in a boiling water reactor as recited in claim 9 wherein step (e.1.1) includes (e.1.1.1) viewing the face of the dial indicator at the remote location using an underwater camera.
 Description Submit all comments and votes
 


BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

1. Field Of the Invention

The present invention relates to boiling water nuclear reactors having a core shroud disposed concentrically within a reactor vessel and a plurality of tie rods installed in tension between vertically spaced sites on the core shroud at a respective plurality of angularly spaced locations about the periphery of the core shroud to axially compress the core shroud as part of a core shroud repair. In particular, the present invention relates to a method and apparatus for measuring the preload on such tie rods after installation in order to detect changes in the axially compressive preload applied to the core shroud by the tie rods.

2. Discussion of the Related Art

Boiling water reactor shrouds are disposed concentrically within reactor vessels to divide the flow of cooling water through the reactor vessels and to structurally support and align the fuel assemblies, steam separator assemblies and control rod guide tubes. The shrouds are generally cylindrical and are typically formed of multiple arcuate steel plates joined by welds along abutting vertical and horizontal edges. After periods of use, cracking of the shroud within heat affected zones of the welds tends to occur as a result of corrosion, radiation and stress. Cracking of the vertically oriented welds is expected to be minor and is considered acceptable because these welds are relatively short in length, relative to the overall shroud length, and because cracking along the vertically oriented welds does not adversely affect the function of the shroud. When excessive cracking of the horizontally oriented welds occurs, however, the shroud must either be replaced or repaired.

U.S. Pat. No. 5,402,570 to Weems et al, the disclosure of which is incorporated herein by reference, describes a method of repairing boiling water reactor core shrouds having horizontal cracks in heat affected zones of welds by securing plural tie rods in vertical orientation about the periphery of the cracked shroud to axially compress the shroud and thereby urge the opposing surfaces of the horizontal cracks toward one another. The method involves securing the tie rods between sites on the core shroud adjacent top and bottom portions of the shroud. Typically, the upper end of each tie rod is threaded and is made to pass through connection hardware, such as a bracket or beam, depending from the top of the shroud. A nut is then threaded onto the upper end of the tie rod and the tie rod tensioned to achieve a desired tie rod preload corresponding to an acceptable level of compression on the shroud. Tensioning of the tie rod is usually accomplished by threading a puller bar onto the upper end of the tie rod and using a hydraulic cylinder to lift the puller bar upwardly in a vertical direction. The nut is then tightened against the bracket so that, when the puller bar is released, an upwardly directed tensile force is exerted on the tie rod by the nut, and a corresponding downwardly directed compressive force is exerted by the nut on the bracket, thereby holding the shroud in axial compression along its length. This axial compression drives the opposing surfaces of any horizontal cracks toward one another, thereby urging the cracks together across all or part of the thickness of the shroud and preventing their adverse effects on the shroud structure. Axial compression of the shroud also improves the ability of the shroud to withstand axial or tensile loads caused by hydrostatic pressures and/or seismic events since such tensile loads are offset by the compressive preload and are thereby mitigated.

It is desirable for an axially compressive preload to be applied continuously to the shroud by the tie rods and for such a preload not to vary significantly from that originally applied by the tie rods at the time of installation; however, preloads can change after installation due, for example, to seismic events and/or thermal transients associated with the start-up and cool-down of the reactor. For example, changes in tie rod preload could occur due to cracking of the core shroud, settling and wear-in of threaded and other mechanical joints, thermal or neutron relaxation of the tie rods, or failure of the tie rods (for example, as a result of cyclic loading of the tie rods caused by thermal transients). To date, however, it has not been practical to detect changes in the axially compressive preload applied to the shroud by the tie rods due to the inaccessibility of the tie rods and the shroud and the highly radioactive and hostile environment within the reactor vessel.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

Accordingly, it is a primary object of the present invention to determine whether the preload on a tie rod has changed following installation of the tie rod in a boiling water reactor as part of a core shroud repair.

Another object of the present invention is to determine whether the preload on a tie rod installed as part of a core shroud repair in a boiling water reactor has changed by remotely measuring the existing preload on the tie rod after the occurrence of a seismic event and/or after a period of operation of the reactor following installation of the tie rod.

It is a further object of the present invention to apply a tensile load to a tie rod installed as part of a core shroud repair in a boiling water reactor and to remotely measure the load applied to the tie rod as well as the axial displacement or deflection of the tie rod in response to the applied load in order to determine the existing tie rod preload.

Yet another object of the present invention is to determine the existing preload on a tie rod installed as part of a core shroud repair in a boiling water reactor by identifying a change in the relationship between the tensile load applied to the tie rod and the resulting axial displacement of the tie rod which occurs when the applied load equals and exceeds the existing tie rod preload.

Some of the advantages of the present invention are that the method and apparatus can be used remotely to assure adequate axial compression of the shroud without having to detorque or unlock the nuts used to set the original tie rod preload, that the method and apparatus can be used upon initial installation of the tie rods and periodically thereafter as part of routine maintenance, and that the method and apparatus minimize reactor downtime and reduce the exposure of personnel to the potentially harmful effects of radiation.

The present invention is generally characterized in a method of measuring tie rod preload in a boiling water nuclear reactor having a core shroud disposed within a reactor vessel and a plurality of tie rods installed in tension between vertically spaced sites on the core shroud at a respective plurality of angularly spaced locations about the periphery of the core shroud as part of a core shroud repair. The method is performed after installation of the tie rods to determine changes in the preload on a tie rod and includes the steps of lowering a tool into the reactor vessel from a remote location positioned externally of the reactor vessel, attaching the tool to an upper portion of a tie rod, using the tool to apply a tensile load along a longitudinal axis of the tie rod, measuring the tensile load applied to the tie rod, measuring axial displacement of the tie rod as a result of the tensile load applied, plotting the load applied versus the axial displacement measured, and identifying a change in slope on the load-displacement plot occurring at a load corresponding to the tie rod preload.

A further aspect of the present invention is generally characterized in a method of measuring tie rod preload in a boiling water nuclear reactor having a core shroud disposed within a reactor vessel and a plurality of tie rods installed in tension between vertically spaced sites on the core shroud at a respective plurality of angularly spaced locations about the periphery of the core shroud as part of a core shroud repair. The method is performed after installation of the tie rods to determine changes in the preload on a tie rod and includes the steps of applying a tensile load along a longitudinal axis of the tie rod, measuring axial displacement of the tie rod in response to the applied tensile load, and remotely viewing the axial displacement measurement from a location externally of the reactor vessel.

Another aspect of the present invention is generally characterized in a tool for measuring tie road preload in a boiling water nuclear reactor having a core shroud disposed within a reactor vessel and a plurality of tie rods installed in tension between vertically spaced sites on the core shroud at a respective plurality of angularly spaced locations about the periphery of the core shroud as part of a core shroud repair, the tool including an elongate support member having an upper end for positioning externally of the reactor vessel and a lower end for positioning inside the reactor vessel adjacent the core shroud, a loading device suspended from the lower end of the support member and including a base for reacting against the core shroud and a puller movable relative to the base and having a configuration to couple with the upper end of a tie rod, a displacement indicator responsive to axial displacement of the puller relative to the base, and a load indicator responsive to axial loading of the tie rod by the puller.

Other objects and advantages of the present invention will become apparent from the following description of the preferred embodiments taken with the accompanying drawings, wherein like parts in each of the several figures are identified by the same reference numerals.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

FIG. 1 is a front view, in elevation, of a tool for measuring tie rod preload in a boiling water reactor according to the present invention.

FIG. 2 is a fragmentary side view, partly in section, of the tie rod preload measurement tool shown in FIG. 1.

FIG. 3 is a fragmentary top view, partly in section, of the tie rod preload measurement tool of FIG. 1 showing a dial indicator mounted therein.

FIG. 4 is a fragmentary side view, partly in section, of a pole attachment for use with the tie rod preload measurement tool according